Business guides – contracts, HR, AI & compliance

DSA Article 10 – an authority requests user data: what are the rules?

How should a digital intermediary handle an authority order for user information under DSA Article 10? Legal basis, formal conditions, acknowledgement, privacy and e-evidence.
Published Mallbutiken
DSA Article 10 – an authority requests user data: what are the rules?

Short answer: If a digital intermediary service receives an official order for information about one or more identified users, Article 10 of the Digital Services Act (DSA) requires the provider to inform the competent authority without undue delay that the order was received and what effect was actually given to it, including whether and when it was acted on. Article 10 does not itself give authorities a new power to obtain user data. The order must rest on other applicable EU or national law, and disclosure must be legally assessed separately. Read the EU Digital Services Act, Article 10.

Editorial legal fact-check: 16 November 2026. Based on Regulation (EU) 2022/2065, Article 10; Sweden's Act (2024:954), Chapter 2, Section 2; and EU electronic-evidence rules. General Swedish/EU legal information, not specific advice about a real order. Actual orders and confidentiality questions may require expert legal review.

Which businesses are covered, and when?

Article 10 concerns providers of intermediary services under the DSA, not merely social media. Depending on the legal definitions it can include hosting or cloud services, online platforms, marketplaces and other intermediary providers. The role must be examined before applying Article 10 to a business supplying only its own content or an unrelated service.

An order must request specific information about one or more specific individual recipients of the service. Article 10 does not itself authorise indiscriminate mass collection, a new registry of every user or a duty to begin collecting data that was never collected for the purpose of providing the service.

Distinguish receipt, acknowledgement and actual disclosure

There are three distinct questions: (1) Was the order really issued by a competent authority and does it meet its formal conditions? (2) Is there a valid, separate legal power for the specific disclosure? (3) What actually happened, and what must be communicated to the authority and the affected user? Merely citing “DSA Article 10” does not answer the second question.

In Sweden, Chapter 2, Section 2 of Act (2024:954) requires covered orders to satisfy Article 10(2). Neither provision should be treated as an independent general power allowing an authority to demand any information it chooses.

Decision matrix: five common situations

These are hypothetical cases. The applicable substantive legal basis and the contents of the order determine the actual result.

SituationLegal questionPractical response
An identified account is specified in a signed authority order.Is the authority competent, is there a separate legal basis, and are Article 10(2) requirements met?Verify authenticity, legal authority, requested details and report actual receipt and effect.
An email cites only “DSA Article 10” and requests the entire user database.Article 10 is not an independent general information-gathering power.Authenticate the sender, request clarification and make a separate legal assessment; do not release raw data.
The order requests data never collected for the service.Article 10(2)(b) concerns data already collected for the service and within the provider's control.Document which categories exist and which do not; check any separate legislation.
An authority in another EU country sends an order in an unfamiliar language.Article 10(2)(c) sets language and electronic-point-of-contact conditions.Check the declared language, translation, authority and legal basis; do not refuse automatically without review.
The order concerns electronic evidence in criminal proceedings and says EPOC or EPOC-PR.EU's separate e-evidence regulation may impose different procedures and deadlines.Route to specialist handling under that legal instrument before disclosing data.

Formal requirements under Article 10(2)

Among other things, a covered order must contain:

  1. Separate legal basis: reference to the relevant provision of Union or national law authorising the order.
  2. Issuing authority: identifying information that enables verification of the sender.
  3. Specific recipient: for example an account ID or unique identifier; a vague group is not sufficient.
  4. Purpose and proportionality: reasons explaining why data are needed to assess legal compliance, subject to the stated exception where reasons cannot be given due to prevention, investigation, detection or prosecution of crime.
  5. Remedies: available redress for the service provider and relevant recipients.
  6. Recipient of effect information: the authority that must receive the effect report, if different from the issuer.
  7. Data and language boundaries: only already-collected data controlled by the provider for provision of the service; the electronic contact point and appropriate language or translation under Articles 10(2)(c) and 11.

These are minimum DSA requirements for orders, not a guarantee of validity or permission to disclose without further review. Article 10(6) preserves applicable national civil and criminal procedure.

Handling an order step by step

  1. Register receipt: securely retain the original order, arrival time, contact point, case reference and owner; do not put users' raw data in open spreadsheets.
  2. Authenticate the sender: verify competent authority and accepted channel against independently obtained details.
  3. Check Article 10(2): legal basis, identifying data, purpose, proportionality, remedies, data scope and language. If deficient, obtain legally reviewed clarification without incorrectly calling it a final refusal.
  4. Assess disclosure law: determine the separate legal authority, procedural rules and any GDPR or confidentiality considerations; check preservation requirements under other instruments.
  5. Inventory existing data: distinguish information already collected and controlled from records that do not exist or would require new collection.
  6. Report receipt and effect: tell the specified authority without undue delay that the order arrived and what actually happened, including if and when it took effect. Never claim data were transmitted unless they were.
  7. Assess user notification: Article 10(5) requires information to the recipient no later than when the order is given effect, or at a time specified in the order. Review applicable procedural law, confidentiality and any specific restrictions before communicating.
  8. Keep verifiable evidence: retain decisions, access-controlled references, secure transfer records, acknowledgements and retention assessment.

These are practical internal controls, not a legally prescribed number of Word or Excel fields.

Scenario 1: an overseas authority requests account information

A Swedish cloud provider receives an order in a language it has not declared, concerning one account. It authenticates the sender, checks Article 10(2)(c)'s language and translation conditions, the user identifiers and the separate substantive legal authority. Only then does it assess which previously collected records could be covered. Originating from an EU authority does not itself require indiscriminate disclosure.

Scenario 2: requested data do not exist

An intermediary is ordered to provide location information for an identified account, but it never recorded those data for the service. Article 10(2)(b) concerns previously collected data within the provider's control. The firm documents what exists and gives an accurate account of the order's effect. Any distinct preservation or data-production duties must be assessed under the legal instrument that actually applies.

Important in 2026: distinguish e-evidence and DSA Articles 9 and 18

EU Regulation (EU) 2023/1543 on electronic evidence applies from 18 August 2026, governing European Production and Preservation Orders (EPOC/EPOC-PR) with distinct requirements. Article 34 also contains a separate start rule for mandatory use of its decentralised IT system. Verify the legal instrument and order type. Read the e-evidence regulation.

DSA Article 9 concerns orders to act against illegal content; the present guide concerns Article 10, information about users. Article 18 concerns hosting providers' own notifications of suspicions of crimes threatening life or safety, without needing an authority order. An order, a moderation action and a crime notification are three different processes.

For related issues, see the Mallbutiken guide to DSA Article 16 (notice and action) and Article 17 (statements of reasons). Neither concerns disclosure orders.

Frequently asked questions

Must we disclose data merely because an authority mentions the DSA?

No. Article 10 does not independently authorise data demands. Check the separate legal basis and the rules for execution.

Can an authority ask for details about all our users?

Article 10 concerns specific information about specific individual service recipients and already-collected data within the provider's control. A request for an entire database does not automatically fit the provision.

Must the user always be informed immediately?

Article 10(5) requires notification no later than effect is given or at the specified time. Applicable national procedure, confidentiality and any specific restrictions must be checked.

Is there a fixed 24- or 72-hour deadline?

No. Article 10(1) says without undue delay. Separate laws, including the e-evidence regulation, may have their own deadlines.

Does an Excel entry prove the data were disclosed?

No. Internal logs can record intended and actual steps, but real disclosure needs independent secure transmission evidence and acknowledgements.

Limit: A document template cannot replace individual legal review, official authority forms or secure personal-data processing. This guide is independently useful without purchasing anything.

Explore the topic

Back to blog
Customers rate us 4.6/5 based on 10261 reviews.